‘First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.’ This saying aptly captures Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s remarkable feat of defenestrating the farce that the PTI government was. On February 27, the world watched in awe – millions said a prayer for their safety – as the Daughter of Destiny’s children, Bilawal and Aseefa, mounted her truck marred with the tragic memories of October 18, 2007 to reconstruct their country’s destiny by ridding it of an inimical and incompetent regime; a regime that has robbed citizens of necessities as basic as roti, kapra and makaan. The PPP’s procession pulsated with the sentiments of those downtrodden and dispossessed masses and its spectacular success messed with the former Prime Minister’s head. However, what threw him off balance and eventually out of office was the vote of no confidence propounded by the PPP Chairman since September 2020: the motion for it submitted with the National Assembly at the conclusion of his arduous ten-day march from Karachi to Islamabad and brought to fruition by former President Asif Ali Zardari’s astute politics, credibility and restoration of the constitution of Pakistan in April 2010.
On April 3, it was clear as daylight that Imran Khan had lost confidence of the august House. In place of an honorable exit, he and his abettors chose to defile the constitution and disenfranchise the representatives of the majority of the population. That he became the first Prime Minister in the country’s history to be voted out through the Parliament on the Constitution Day, also the anniversary of Shaheed Mohtarmah Benazir Bhutto’s glorious homecoming to Lahore in 1986 to fight Zia’s brutal dictatorship is redolent of divine retribution. While it is hurtful to witness the ignominious fall of Pakistan’s cricketing legend, let us make no bones about the fact that he is a fascist who has sullied our democracy, undermined our national interests and fractured our polity in his quest to attain and retain power.
A fascist’s manual consists of tactics such as propaganda, victimhood, unreality, anti-intellectualism, espousal of patriarchy, perversion of law and demolition of public unity, order and welfare. Imran Khan is adept at each one of them. His is a politics based on deception, deflection and disruption. ‘35 Punctures’ was the catchword when PTI could not win general elections in 2013; a fabrication about rigging peddled without remorse that held the functioning of the state hostage for four months and led to attacks on the Parliament House and Pakistan Television. Come 2022. As soon as his numerical support for office withered, Khan resorted to shamanistic incantation of a foreign conspiracy bankrolled by American dollars to dislodge his government. Identical to the ‘Pizza-gate’ launched during the 2016 US Presidential election to tarnish the Clinton campaign, the ‘Letter-gate’ connects its targets – everyone who sits on the other side of the aisle – to acts of bribery and treachery. The repercussion was similar: armed men arrived at the gates of Sindh House, the site of this alleged Faustian bargain and dissenting politicians relentlessly hounded. Like a prototypical fascist, the former Prime Minister has constructed a gravely divisive narrative by labeling his opponents as enemies of Pakistan and Islam and calling for their social exclusion. His self-deifying assertion that there is no alternative to him, that he alone is patriotic, true believer and incorruptible has ready followers and when truth becomes oracular rather than factual, evidence becomes irrelevant.
Contradiction is the hallmark of fascists and openly embraced by their disciples. The conspiracy theory about foreign conspiracy is replete with it but so are the rest of Imran Khan’s claims. He promised to ‘drain the swamp’ and recover the nation’s looted money but his anti-corruption campaign concealed a vindictive agenda; like Nazi Germany, the Niazi regime mainstreamed all kinds of mafias and bled Pakistan dry. A government that pontificated about national honor mortgaged its economic sovereignty to international financial institutions. Examples were quoted of Caliph Umar (RA)’s probity but the details of gifts received by the Prime Minister were never disclosed. ‘Do nahi, aik Pakistan’ was PTI’s rallying cry but the huts of the poor were demolished and bungalows of the rich regularized. Khan waxed lyrical about the British parliamentary system but converted Pakistan’s Parliament into a madhouse and ruled by decree. When push came to shove, the captain fled the field and began to cry foul.
The Deputy Speaker’s subversion of the constitution to thwart the opposition from voting on the no confidence motion on the pretext of disloyalty to the state was Pakistan’s Reichstag Fire moment. Hitler exploited it to arrest all communist members of the Reichstag, win a decisive electoral victory and impose a state of emergency in Germany that lasted twelve years. Khan’s ambitions were no different but fortunately, the Supreme Court stood in the way. Like the military, it is also under fire by zealous supporters of the PTI for upholding the constitution and adhering to professional ethics because that is what fascists do: incapacitate institutions to evade accountability and rule with impunity. This abandonment of reason, contempt for rule of law and degeneration of promising men and women into a mob is recipe for national disaster. We must defend our institutions to avert it. The 33-year-old Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has shown us how it is done by spearheading the movement to oust Imran Khan’s totalitarian regime constitutionally, legally, democratically and peacefully – through the same Parliament that installed him in power in the first place. He did so, not to wrest control of the high office but to liberate it from a demagogue not worthy of it.
‘Fascism is a lie told by bullies.’ Ernest Hemingway could not have been more straightforward. The heir of Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Shaheed Mohtarmah Benazir Bhutto has shown Imran Khan the door. Now, we must support him to weed out his noxious brand of politics from our country. Long Live Pakistan!